I love the Muppets. I grew up watching the movies, have watched the entire Muppet Show series multiple times, and have use far too many quotes in my actual daily life. I even wrote a research paper on the Muppet Show for my History of Television class in college.

When the film The Muppets came out a few years ago, I loved it for being modern, yet being true to all the silliness and heart of the original Muppets material. The announcement for Muppets: Most Wanted filled me with hope, excitement and puns.

Muppets: Most Wanted, however, is like the barbecue restaurant near my neighborhood whose delicious smell permeates the air as I walk or drive by, beckoning me. Once I sit at the table and the food comes, it looks as good as it smells. But then I taste it.

It’s pretty good, but is far from the savory smell I had been anticipating, and could be so much better.

In fact, the Lego Movie is almost a better Muppet movie.

What Worked

The Muppety Silliness

The plot is a silly, farcical adventure with gags jokes, and Brechtian moments (breaking the fourth wall). The entire movie pivots around a single gag: That with only the difference of a mole, Kermit is confused for the evil jewel thief, Constantine. There is chaos, there is silliness, there are chickens, explosions, bad jokes, a Muppet News Flash or two, and plenty of ridiculous moments.

The Muppets themselves remain true to character, which is a tricky accomplishment. Often, Miss Piggy can be portrayed as more selfish and mean than originally, but this time they remained true. Kermit’s ability as a leader allows him to excel in the Russian prison. Even the key humans, Ricky Gervais, Ty Burrell, and Tina Fey, bring a Muppetiness to the movie. They blend with the Muppets, helping build the supposed reality.

Staying true to the original Muppety spirit is not an easy feat, and that’s where this movie stays on its feet. (I was going for a Muppety pun, but I don’t think it worked.)

Musical Numbers

Once again, Bret McKenzie uses the silliness he honed from Flight of the Conchords and adapts it to the Muppet world. While none of the songs quite reach the greatness of “Am I A Man Or A Muppet?”, but remain fun, snappy, and full of wry humor. In short, not the greatest Muppet songs, but definitely worthy of the overall canon.

I think the top two are “We’re Making A Sequel” (see above), and “The Interrogation” (below). My third favorite would have to be the Russian prisoners singing a song from Chorus Line.

Celebrity Cameos

Part of the success of the Muppets is the integration and random arrival of current and legendary celebrities. From the hosts of the Muppet Show, to the random appearance of celebrities in bit parts, part of the fun is seeing how many celebrities show up. I love the Christopher Waltz Waltz, the willingness of Salma Hayek to wear a ridiculous costume, the many known celebrities among the Russian prisoners (especially the one locked in a box), and the random appearance of Tom Hiddleston. These are all great, small throw away moments that add just a touch to all of the giggling.

 What Didn’t Work

90’s References

While both The Muppets and Muppets: Most Wanted are built on nostalgia for the Muppet Show, the nostalgia in this film for the 90’s was random. Just random, not Muppet joke random.

First, Kermit is brought into the Russian jail in Hannibal Lecter gear.

 

Not only is this from the early 90’s, but it is also a reference to a really disturbing and non-Muppety movie.

Second, Miss Piggy’s grand number becomes a magnificent duet with Celine Dion. While Celine Dion remains a legend, and the whole sequence embraces its ridiculousness, it is odd. 

Although, Miss Piggy does look amazing in the tweed outfit worn during the song.

Too Many Plot Lines

I think this is where the movie was weakest. Here are the plots and sub-plots in the film:

• Kermit is trying to keep The Muppets organized and together as they go on a world tour
• Kermit is being undermined by Dominic, and feels unneeded by his Muppet family
• Constantine and Dominic Badguy (Ricky Gervais) are using the Muppet World Tour to cover their heists
• Miss Piggy attempts to get Kermit to marry her, again. (Though, I thought they officially got married during The Muppets Take Manhattan)
• Sam The Eagle works with Interpol Agent Jean Pierre Napoleon (Ty Burrell in an Inspector Clouseau style role) to investigate the heists.
• Kermit is made to look like Constantine, and is sent to Russian prison and tries to escape
• Nadia, the lead guard of the Russian Prison,(Tina Fey), has Kermit lead the prisoners in putting on their annual talent show, and ends up falling in love with Kermit

While some of those can be grouped, that is seven plot lines. Let’s compare this to the original Muppet Movie:

• Kermit goes on a road trip to Hollywood to become a star. Along the way, he makes friends and they join his journey.
• Doc Hopper chases Kermit to force him to be the spokesfrog for Hoppers Fried Frog Legs, a fast food chain.
• Miss Piggy and Kermit have a troubled romance

Seven vs. three plot lines.

The plethora of plot in Muppets: Most Wanted waters down the potential for the whole movie. Each of the plots is entertaining, and they do build to an overall story, yet there does not feel like there is an over-arching plot. The film feels a little scattered as it jumps between one story and another. If it could have been a bit more focused, like The Great Muppet Caper, it could still have the heist element, but been much more fun.

What We Have To Look Forward To

This is a tricky question. Coming in with about $50,000,000 domestic and $78,000,000 worldwide, the movie has squeaked in enough from the box office to break even. It might pick up a bit more with blu-ray/DVD sales, and merchandise tie-ins, but this is not a high enough number to guarantee a sequel. Just like most of the movie, it is good, but not amazing.

I hope we can have more of this team bringing us Muppets. They are bringing the best Muppet material we have seen in decades, and they might hit a third film out of the ball park. Hopefully, Disney will give this franchise one more shot, and the film makers can bring a bit more heart and focus to the silliness.

• What did you think of Muppets: Most Wanted?
• What was your favorite part? What would you have done to make it more awesome?
• If you were to have a Muppet spin-off movie, which character would you base it on?
• Have you ever been disappointed by a restaurant where the smell was much better than the actual food?
• If you were a Muppet, what type of restaurant would you go to?

SIDE NOTE 1: There really isn’t an answer of what to look forward to for The Muppets, so instead, we’ll look forward to theoretical spaceships which may become a reality within our lifetime. Check this out. WHAT!?!

SIDE NOTE 2: Here’s the trailer for The Legend of Korra